{"total":22,"page":1,"pageSize":25,"pages":1,"millis":0,"query":{"q":"","state":"","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","kind":"duty","level":"court","type":"","quarter":"","grade":"","collection":"","from":"2021-06-01","to":"","sort":"relevance"},"items":[{"id":"DUT-AL-021","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Alabama (United States District Court for the Middle District of Alabama, Northern Division)","state":"AL","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-AL","issuer":"United States District Court, M.D. Ala. (Watkins, J.)","instrument":"Case v. Ivey, No. 2:20-cv-777-WKW, Doc. 54 (M.D. Ala. June 1, 2021) (Memorandum and Opinion Order)","title":"Jennifer Case, et al. v. Kay Ivey, in her individual capacity and official capacity as Governor of Alabama, et al.","dateIssued":"2021-06-01","startDate":"2021-06-01","endDate":"2021-09-30","quarters":["2021Q2","2021Q3"],"types":["STAY","CLOSE","GATH","MASK","EMP","DUTY"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-AL-021","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-AL-021"},{"id":"DUT-WA-020","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Washington (United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, on appeal from E.D. Wash.)","state":"WA","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-WA","issuer":"United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (Gould, Clifton, Bress, JJ.; opinion by Judge Clifton)","instrument":"Slidewaters LLC v. Washington State Department of Labor \u0026 Industries, No. 20-35634","title":"Opinion affirming denial of injunctive relief and dismissal of claims against Proclamations 20-05 and 20-25 and L\u0026I emergency rule WAC 296-800-14035","dateIssued":"2021-07-08","startDate":"2021-07-08","endDate":"2021-09-30","quarters":["2021Q3"],"types":["CLOSE","EMP","COND"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-WA-020","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-WA-020"},{"id":"DUT-MO-015","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Missouri (St. Louis County orders; Eighth Circuit)","state":"MO","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-MO","issuer":"United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit (Colloton, J., joined by Kelly and Stras, JJ.)","instrument":"Hawse v. Page, No. 20-1960 (8th Cir. July 30, 2021), reported at 7 F.4th 685","title":"Lauren Hawse, et al. v. Sam Page, County Executive of St. Louis County, and Faisal Khan, Director of the St. Louis County Public Health Department","dateIssued":"2021-07-30","startDate":"2021-07-30","endDate":"2021-09-30","quarters":["2021Q3"],"types":["STAY","GATH","CAP","MASK","DUTY"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-MO-015","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-MO-015"},{"id":"DUT-NJ-013","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"New Jersey","state":"NJ","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-NJ","issuer":"Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division (published opinion, Docket No. A-0639-20; on appeal from the Law Division, Sussex County, L-0388-20)","instrument":"JWC Fitness, LLC v. Murphy, No. A-0639-20 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Oct. 18, 2021) (approved for publication)","title":"JWC Fitness, LLC v. Philip D. Murphy, Governor of New Jersey, et al.: no statutory or constitutional compensation for the closure and capacity limits imposed on a gym by EOs 104, 107 and successors","dateIssued":"2021-10-18","startDate":"2021-10-18","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["CLOSE","CAP","EMER","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-NJ-013","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-NJ-013"},{"id":"DUT-OK-019","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Oklahoma","state":"OK","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-OK","issuer":"Supreme Court of Oklahoma (Kauger, J., for the Court)","instrument":"Ho v. Tulsa Spine \u0026 Specialty Hospital, L.L.C., 2021 OK 68, 507 P.3d 673, Case No. 119,752","title":"Opinion reversing dismissal of a nurse\u0027s wrongful-discharge action: the Governor\u0027s COVID-19 emergency orders expressed established Oklahoma public policy binding a private hospital","dateIssued":"2021-12-14","startDate":"2021-12-14","endDate":"","quarters":["2020Q2"],"types":["DUTY","HC","EMP","COND"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-OK-019","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-OK-019"},{"id":"DUT-CA-019","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"California","state":"CA","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-CA","issuer":"California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District","instrument":"Published opinion: See\u0027s Candies, Inc. v. Superior Court (Ek), No. B312241 (Cal. Ct. App. Dec. 21, 2021), 73 Cal.App.5th 66","title":"See\u0027s Candies, Inc. v. Superior Court: a wrongful-death action alleging that an employee contracted COVID-19 at work \u0027because of defendants\u0027 failure to implement adequate safety measures\u0027 and infected her husband is not barred by workers\u0027 compensation exclusivity; the derivative-injury doctrine does not reach the household member\u0027s claim","dateIssued":"2021-12-21","startDate":"2021-12-21","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["DUTY","EMP"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-CA-019","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-CA-019"},{"id":"DUT-IA-017","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Iowa","state":"IA","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-IA","issuer":"Supreme Court of Iowa (Mansfield, J., for a unanimous court)","instrument":"Riley Drive Entertainment I, Inc. v. Reynolds, No. 20-1510 (Iowa Feb. 18, 2022) (amended Apr. 7, 2022)","title":"Riley Drive Entertainment I, Inc. d/b/a Tonic Bar, et al. v. Governor Kimberly K. Reynolds and Iowa Department of Public Health - opinion affirming dismissal as moot","dateIssued":"2022-02-18","startDate":"2022-02-18","endDate":"","quarters":["2020Q3","2020Q4"],"types":["CLOSE","ALC","COND"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-IA-017","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-IA-017"},{"id":"DUT-HI-016","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Hawaii (Intermediate Court of Appeals of the State of Hawaii)","state":"HI","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-HI","issuer":"Intermediate Court of Appeals of the State of Hawaii (published opinion)","instrument":"For Our Rights v. Ige, No. CAAP-21-0000024, Opinion of the Court (Haw. Ct. App. Feb. 25, 2022) (for publication)","title":"For Our Rights v. Ige","dateIssued":"2022-02-25","startDate":"2022-02-25","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["EMER","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-HI-016","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-HI-016"},{"id":"DUT-FED-073","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"United States (Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission)","state":"","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-FED","issuer":"Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission, Chief Administrative Law Judge Covette Rooney","instrument":"Secretary of Labor v. Ariana Murrell-Rosario d/b/a Liberty Tax Service, OSHRC Docket No. 21-0432, Decision and Order (June 6, 2022)","title":"Decision and Order, OSHRC Docket No. 21-0432 (Liberty Tax Service, Lynn, Massachusetts)","dateIssued":"2022-06-06","startDate":"2022-06-06","endDate":"","quarters":["2021Q1","2021Q2"],"types":["EMP","MASK"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-FED-073","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-FED-073"},{"id":"DUT-GA-017","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Georgia (Court of Appeals of Georgia, Third Division)","state":"GA","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-GA","issuer":"Court of Appeals of Georgia (Doyle, P.J., with Reese, J., and Senior Appellate Judge Phipps)","instrument":"Arbor Management Services, LLC v. Hendrix, No. A22A0068 (Ga. Ct. App. June 22, 2022)","title":"Opinion reversing the denial of a motion to dismiss: negligence claims for a senior-living facility\u0027s March 2020 infection-control conduct are barred by the Georgia COVID-19 Pandemic Business Safety Act absent gross negligence","dateIssued":"2022-06-22","startDate":"2022-06-22","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["DUTY","COND"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-GA-017","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-GA-017"},{"id":"DUT-NC-018","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"North Carolina","state":"NC","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-NC","issuer":"Court of Appeals of North Carolina","instrument":"Kinsley v. Ace Speedway Racing, Ltd., 2022-NCCOA-524, No. COA21-428 (N.C. Ct. App. Aug. 2, 2022)","title":"Opinion: the terms of the June 8, 2020 Abatement Order (close until Order 141 expires or until a plan for \u0027full compliance with Order 141\u0027s mass gathering restrictions\u0027), the June 11, 2020 TRO and the July 10, 2020 preliminary injunction","dateIssued":"2022-08-02","startDate":"2022-08-02","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["GATH","CLOSE","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-NC-018","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-NC-018"},{"id":"DUT-OR-017","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Oregon","state":"OR","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-OR","issuer":"Oregon Court of Appeals","instrument":"JGB Enterprises, LLC v. Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission, 325 Or App 326, 529 P3d 262 (Apr. 19, 2023) (A176066): judicial review affirming a default order suspending a Lane County saloon\u0027s liquor license for 38 days for violating EO 20-66 and OHA guidance \u0027that qualified as public health laws\u0027 during Extreme Risk (Jan. 4-Feb. 20, 2021)","title":"JGB Enterprises, LLC, dba Twisted River Saloon, Petitioner, v. Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission, Respondent","dateIssued":"2023-04-19","startDate":"2023-04-19","endDate":"","quarters":["2021Q1"],"types":["CLOSE","MASK","CAP","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-OR-017","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-OR-017"},{"id":"DUT-MI-019","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Michigan","state":"MI","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-MI","issuer":"Michigan Court of Appeals (Boonstra, P.J., and Gadola and Yates, JJ.; opinion by Gadola, J.), on appeal from the Court of Claims, No. 21-000075-MM","instrument":"T \u0026 V Associates, Inc. v. Director of Health and Human Services, No. 361727 (Mich. Ct. App. June 29, 2023) (for publication)","title":"Published opinion on a banquet caterer\u0027s challenge to the MDHHS Gatherings and Face Mask Order of March 19, 2021: the orders under MCL 333.2253 \u0027directly restricted plaintiff\u0027s ability to operate its business\u0027 and \u0027contained criminal sanctions for violators\u0027; MCL 333.2253 held an unconstitutional delegation of legislative power; Court of Claims reversed","dateIssued":"2023-06-29","startDate":"2023-06-29","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["GATH","CAP","MASK","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-MI-019","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-MI-019"},{"id":"DUT-CA-020","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"California","state":"CA","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-CA","issuer":"Supreme Court of California (Corrigan, J., for a unanimous court)","instrument":"Opinion: Kuciemba v. Victory Woodworks, Inc., No. S274191 (Cal. July 6, 2023), 14 Cal.5th 993","title":"Kuciemba v. Victory Woodworks: employers \u0027allowed to continue operations during this time were subject to strict regulations designed to limit transmission of the virus\u0027; the county health order \u0027mandated specific health and safety precautions\u0027; the employer remains under \u0027the default duty to use due care in its operations\u0027; no tort duty runs to employees\u0027 household members","dateIssued":"2023-07-06","startDate":"2023-07-06","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["DUTY","EMP"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-CA-020","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-CA-020"},{"id":"DUT-AZ-019","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"United States (9th Cir.)","state":"AZ","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-AZ","issuer":"United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (published opinion; Hurwitz, J., concurring)","instrument":"Published opinion","title":"Miller v. City of Scottsdale, No. 22-16004 (9th Cir. Dec. 8, 2023)","dateIssued":"2023-12-08","startDate":"2023-12-08","endDate":"","quarters":["2020Q2"],"types":["CLOSE","DUTY"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-AZ-019","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-AZ-019"},{"id":"DUT-MT-019","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Montana","state":"MT","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-MT","issuer":"Supreme Court of Montana (Gustafson, J.)","instrument":"Stand Up Montana v. Missoula County Public Schools, 2023 MT 240, No. DA 23-0046 (Mont. Dec. 12, 2023)","title":"Opinion affirming summary judgment for the Missoula County school districts on the substantive due process challenge to their 2021-22 mask requirements","dateIssued":"2023-12-12","startDate":"2023-12-12","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["MASK","SCH","EMP"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-MT-019","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-MT-019"},{"id":"DUT-OR-016","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Oregon","state":"OR","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-OR","issuer":"Oregon Court of Appeals (Kamins, J., with Tookey, P.J., and Egan, J.); review denied by the Oregon Supreme Court","instrument":"Along Came Trudy LLC v. Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission, 330 Or App 295, 543 P3d 751 (Jan. 24, 2024), rev den, 372 Or 588 (July 18, 2024) (A178679; OLCC21V003): judicial review affirming cancellation of a Lane County restaurant and event venue\u0027s liquor license for three violations of EO 20-66 (indoor dining while prohibited)","title":"Along Came Trudy LLC, dba Along Came Trudy, Petitioner, v. Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission, Respondent","dateIssued":"2024-01-24","startDate":"2024-01-24","endDate":"2024-07-18","quarters":["2020Q4","2021Q1"],"types":["CLOSE","CAP","MASK","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-OR-016","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-OR-016"},{"id":"DUT-MN-018","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Minnesota","state":"MN","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-MN","issuer":"Supreme Court of Minnesota (Moore, III, J.; Anderson, J., concurring; Procaccini, J., took no part)","instrument":"Snell v. Walz, No. A21-0626 (Minn. May 10, 2024), 6 N.W.3d 458","title":"Snell v. Walz (Snell II): the Emergency Management Act authorizes the declaration of a peacetime emergency in response to a pandemic; no evidentiary showing required; no unconstitutional delegation","dateIssued":"2024-05-10","startDate":"2024-05-10","endDate":"","quarters":["2020Q2","2020Q3","2020Q4","2021Q1","2021Q2","2021Q3"],"types":["EMER","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-MN-018","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-MN-018"},{"id":"DUT-DE-012","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Delaware","state":"DE","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-DE","issuer":"Supreme Court of Delaware (Seitz, C.J.; Valihura, Traynor, LeGrow and Griffiths, JJ., en banc)","instrument":"Opinion, In re COVID-Related Restrictions on Religious Services, No. 354, 2023 (Del. Aug. 1, 2024) (affirming the Court of Chancery, C.A. No. 2021-1036, and the Superior Court, C.A. No. N23C-01-123)","title":"In re COVID-Related Restrictions on Religious Services (Del. Aug. 1, 2024)","dateIssued":"2024-08-01","startDate":"2024-08-01","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["DUTY","CLOSE","GATH"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-DE-012","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-DE-012"},{"id":"DUT-NC-017","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"North Carolina","state":"NC","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-NC","issuer":"Supreme Court of North Carolina","instrument":"Kinsley v. Ace Speedway Racing, Ltd., No. 280PA22 (N.C. Aug. 23, 2024), affirming 284 N.C. App. 665 (2022)","title":"Opinion: the June 8, 2020 NCDHHS abatement order closing Ace Speedway as an \u0027imminent hazard\u0027 for hosting gatherings above the EO 141 limit, the Governor\u0027s letter that the races \u0027were criminal acts\u0027, the preliminary injunction enforcing the order, and the sufficiency of the speedway\u0027s constitutional counterclaims","dateIssued":"2024-08-23","startDate":"2024-08-23","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["GATH","CLOSE","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-NC-017","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-NC-017"},{"id":"DUT-OR-018","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"Oregon","state":"OR","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-OR","issuer":"Oregon Court of Appeals (Shorr, P.J., with Pagan, J., and O\u0027Connor, J.)","instrument":"Central Pastime, LLC v. Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission, 342 Or App 391 (Aug. 6, 2025) (A180094; OLCCV024): judicial review affirming a 72-day liquor-license suspension for failing to require employees and customers to wear face coverings on Dec. 2, 2020 (OHA July 24, 2020 guidance) and Mar. 27, 2021 (EO 20-66)","title":"In the Matter of the Full-On Premises Sales License Held By Central Pastime, LLC, dba Central Pastime, Petitioner, v. Oregon Liquor and Cannabis Commission, Respondent","dateIssued":"2025-08-06","startDate":"2025-08-06","endDate":"","quarters":["2020Q4","2021Q1"],"types":["MASK","EMP","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-OR-018","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-OR-018"},{"id":"DUT-NC-019","kind":"duty","level":"court","jurisdiction":"North Carolina","state":"NC","metro":"","industry":"","agency":"","collection":"DUT-NC","issuer":"Supreme Court of North Carolina","instrument":"North Carolina Bar and Tavern Ass\u0027n v. Stein, No. 126PA24 (N.C. Aug. 22, 2025), on review of 293 N.C. App. 402 (2024)","title":"Opinion: the Emergency Management Act \u0027grants the Governor the ability to impose significant restrictions or prohibitions on otherwise permissible activity during states of emergency\u0027, including restrictions on \u0027the operation of offices, business establishments, and other places to or from which people may travel or at which they may congregate\u0027; no statutory compensation for such restrictions","dateIssued":"2025-08-22","startDate":"2025-08-22","endDate":"","quarters":[],"types":["CLOSE","ALC","OTHER"],"grade":"primary","fileExists":true,"url":"/library/DUT-NC-019","exhibitUrl":"/exhibit/DUT-NC-019"}],"facets":{"kind":[{"value":"duty","label":"Standing duty","count":22}],"level":[{"value":"court","label":"Court","count":22}],"state":[{"value":"NC","label":"North Carolina","count":3},{"value":"OR","label":"Oregon","count":3},{"value":"CA","label":"California","count":2},{"value":"AL","label":"Alabama","count":1},{"value":"AZ","label":"Arizona","count":1},{"value":"DE","label":"Delaware","count":1},{"value":"GA","label":"Georgia","count":1},{"value":"HI","label":"Hawaii","count":1},{"value":"IA","label":"Iowa","count":1},{"value":"MI","label":"Michigan","count":1},{"value":"MN","label":"Minnesota","count":1},{"value":"MO","label":"Missouri","count":1},{"value":"MT","label":"Montana","count":1},{"value":"NJ","label":"New Jersey","count":1},{"value":"OK","label":"Oklahoma","count":1},{"value":"WA","label":"Washington","count":1}],"type":[{"value":"CLOSE","label":"Business closure","count":11},{"value":"OTHER","label":"Other","count":10},{"value":"DUTY","label":"Standing duty","count":8},{"value":"EMP","label":"Workplace rules","count":8},{"value":"MASK","label":"Face-covering requirement","count":8},{"value":"GATH","label":"Gathering cap","count":6},{"value":"CAP","label":"Capacity limit","count":5},{"value":"COND","label":"Operating condition","count":4},{"value":"EMER","label":"Emergency declaration","count":3},{"value":"ALC","label":"Alcohol and bars","count":2},{"value":"STAY","label":"Stay-at-home","count":2},{"value":"HC","label":"Health care orders","count":1},{"value":"SCH","label":"Schools and child care","count":1}],"quarter":[{"value":"2021Q1","label":"2021 Q1","count":5},{"value":"2020Q4","label":"2020 Q4","count":4},{"value":"2021Q3","label":"2021 Q3","count":4},{"value":"2020Q2","label":"2020 Q2","count":3},{"value":"2021Q2","label":"2021 Q2","count":3},{"value":"2020Q3","label":"2020 Q3","count":2}],"grade":[{"value":"primary","label":"Primary source read","count":22}],"industry":[],"agency":[]}}